Vaccinated children 3X more likely to get flu -
Flu Shot Not Effective in Preventing Flu-Related Hospitalizations in Asthmatic Children
ATS 2009, SAN DIEGO— The inactivated flu vaccine does not appear to be effective in preventing
influenza-related hospitalizations in children, especially the ones with asthma. In fact, children who get
the flu vaccine are more at risk for hospitalization than their peers who do not get the vaccine, according
to new research that will be presented on Tuesday, May 19, at the 105th International Conference of the
American Thoracic Society in San Diego.
Flu vaccine (trivalent inactivated flu vaccine—TIV) has unknown effects on asthmatics.
“The concerns that vaccination maybe associated with asthma exacerbations have been disproved
with multiple studies in the past, but the vaccine’s effectiveness has not been well-established,” said Avni
Joshi, M.D., of the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, MN. “This study was aimed at evaluating the effectiveness
of the TIV in children overall, as well as the children with asthma, to prevent influenza-related
The CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) and the American Academy
of Pediatrics (AAP) recommend annual influenza vaccination for all children aged six months to 18 years.
- 2 -
The National Asthma Education and Prevention Program (3rd revision) also recommends annual flu
vaccination of asthmatic children older than six months.
In order to determine whether the vaccine was effective in reducing the number of
hospitalizations that all children, and especially the ones with asthma, faced over eight consecutive flu
seasons, the researchers conducted a cohort study of 263 children who were evaluated at the Mayo Clinic
in Minnesota from six months to 18 years of age, each of whom had had laboratory-confirmed influenza
between 1996 to 2006. The investigators determined who had and had not received the flu vaccine, their
asthma status and who did and did not require hospitalization. Records were reviewed for each subject
with influenza-related illness for flu vaccination preceding the illness and hospitalization during that
They found that children who had received the flu vaccine had three times the risk of
hospitalization, as compared to children who had not received the vaccine. In asthmatic children, there
was a significantly higher risk of hospitalization in subjects who received the TIV, as compared to those
who did not (p= 0.006). But no other measured factors—such as insurance plans or severity of asthma—
appeared to affect risk of hospitalization.
“While these findings do raise questions about the efficacy of the vaccine, they do not in fact
implicate it as a cause of hospitalizations,” said Dr. Joshi. “More studies are needed to assess not only the
immunogenicity, but also the efficacy of different influenza vaccines in asthmatic subjects.”